Sacred but Suffering: The Paradox of Reverence and Neglect in India

Source: Dr Catherine ( Flickr )

India, a land steeped in mythology and spirituality, has long revered elements of the natural world as sacred. Animals like the cow—worshipped as Gau Mata (Mother Cow)—and the Ganges river dolphin—an ancient denizen of the revered river—are imbued with divine status in cultural memory and religious practice. Yet, beneath this spiritual symbolism lies a stark reality: these very icons of devotion are increasingly victims of neglect, environmental degradation, and systemic apathy.

This paradox is not unique to India—it reflects a universal human contradiction. We enshrine the natural world in rituals and beliefs but often fail to protect it in practice. Understanding this gap between reverence and responsibility is the first step toward meaningful conservation.

1. The Cow: From Sacred Symbol to Stray Statistic

Worship without Welfare

In Hinduism, the cow represents non-violence, fertility, and sustenance. Yet, today, India faces a growing crisis involving over 5.2 million stray cattle (as per the 2022 Livestock Census). These animals are often seen rummaging through landfills, ingesting plastic and toxins that lead to fatal digestive blockages and poisoning.

A Byproduct of Industrialized Dairy

India is the largest producer of milk in the world, with over 200 million tons annually, driven by the dairy industry's reliance on continuous, high-yield milk production. Once cows stop producing milk efficiently, they are often abandoned. This system also entails:

• Forced impregnations and early calf separation, which cause emotional and physical distress.

• Zero-grazing dairies where cows live in confined, unsanitary spaces, raising their susceptibility to infections and injuries.

• Inadequate veterinary care for aging or sick animals.

• 
  

Illegal Slaughter: The Hidden Economy

Despite slaughter bans in 24 states, illegal transport and butchery of cattle persist. This underground industry feeds both domestic and international demand, with animal trafficking routes stretching across states. Reports from the Animal Welfare Board of India and NGOs reveal widespread cruelty in transport and slaughter methods, often violating the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960.

2. The Ganges Dolphin: Sacred River, Polluted Grave

Echoes from a Vanishing Species

Platanista gangetica, the Ganges river dolphin, has been an integral part of South Asia’s aquatic biodiversity for over 20 million years. Once flourishing, the species is now listed as Endangered by the IUCN, with fewer than 2,500 individuals remaining in fragmented habitats along the Ganga, Brahmaputra, and Meghna river systems.

Drowning in a Toxic Stream

Despite its status as a national aquatic animal since 2009 and an integral figure in local mythology, the dolphin faces daily existential threats:

• Bioaccumulation of heavy metals such as lead, mercury, and arsenic from industrial effluents impacts the dolphins' reproductive and neurological health.

• Hydrological barriers—over 50 major dams and barrages along the Ganges—interrupt migratory routes, isolate populations, and alter sediment and prey availability.

• Acoustic pollution from motorized vessels impairs the dolphin’s echolocation-based hunting and communication, leading to stress and disorientation.

  
  

Bycatch and Brutality

Entanglement in gill nets and katara (traditional fishing nets) leads to fatal injuries. Fisherfolk often see dolphins as competition or bycatch, and accidental deaths are rarely reported. Studies by the Wildlife Institute of India have documented a steady decline in sightings and breeding populations across key river stretches.

Bridging the Gap: From Reverence to Responsibility

The fate of the cow and dolphin reflects how symbolism without support can lead to ecological collapse. Sacredness must be backed by science, policy, and community engagement.

What Needs to Change?

For the Cow:

• Strengthen and scale up the capacity of gaushalas (cow shelters) with modern facilities and transparent funding models.

• Regulate and reform the dairy industry to include ethical dairy certifications, focusing on animal welfare standards.

• Incentivize the adoption of non-dairy livestock roles (e.g., cow dung-based biogas or sustainable agriculture practices).

  
  

For the Ganges Dolphin:

• Implement stricter pollution control mechanisms under existing programs like Namami Gange, ensuring actual reductions in BOD (Biochemical Oxygen Demand) and industrial discharge.

• Establish no-fishing zones and acoustic buffer regions in dolphin habitats.

• Promote community-led river stewardship models that involve local fishers in conservation efforts through training and livelihood support.

A Universal Mirror

From lions on national emblems to whales in tribal mythologies, many societies elevate certain animals to symbolic heights yet allow them to fade in reality. This is a reflection of a larger human flaw: selective affection and inconsistent stewardship.

Whether it’s the Amazon rainforest burned for cattle, or elephants paraded for festivals, or coral reefs loved in postcards but bleached by tourism and warming oceans, the contradiction remains.

Toward a New Sacred Ecology

The cow and the Ganges dolphin are not just symbols of India’s ecological and spiritual wealth—they are barometers of its environmental conscience. To honor them truly, we must move from ritualistic reverence to systemic reform, where science, policy, and spirituality converge.

Reverence must evolve into responsibility. Only then can sanctity translate into survival.